Close Ad

Judge Issues Woman a $300 Parking Fine - Her Starving Daughter Changes His Mind
kind judge dismisses mother's $300 fine after asking her to buy her daughter breakfast
Uplifting News

Judge Issues Woman a $300 Parking Fine - Her Starving Daughter Changes His Mind

One kind judge decided to let a woman out of her parking ticket if she would agree to buy her daughter breakfast.

A judge in Providence won over the internet after his kindness with a parking ticket case went viral.

The case, which was seen on the show Caught in Providence and shared by Wonderbot, involved a mother who had been accused of parking her car on a sidewalk. For that, she was given a $100 ticket, but she refused to pay so the fine tripled to $300.


In court, the woman pleaded her case as her two daughters joined her. But interestingly, the judge was more interested in talking to one of her daughters than the mother.

Judge Caprio Finds Out Why a Mother Parked Her Car on the Sidewalk

The judge asked 6-year-old Janice to stand next to him and proceeded to ask her a few questions, including her favourite subjects at school (Math and English) and what she wanted to be when she grew up (a teacher). Caprio was delighted by the latter response since he had been a teacher before he passed the bar to become a lawyer and ultimately a judge.

Wonderful thing for you to do. That’s a great job... You get a great joy from teaching?

Judge Caprio

But Caprio did have a case to run, so he asked Janice's mom for some self-reflection about why she parked on a sidewalk.

"I went to my cousin's house to pick up something," she responded. "They were having a party and I didn't want nobody to hit my car so I went on the sidewalk."

How a 6-Year-Old Girl Decided Her Mother's Fate in Court

Caprio decided to ask Janice what he should do. He could charge her mom with the entire $300 fine, or have her just pay $100, as the ticket originally said. But then he presented a third option: He could cut the fine to $50 or even drop the charges altogether.

Janice's response was honest and respectable: Her mom should be charged $50.

But then Caprio asked Janice what she had for breakfast that morning

I didn't have anything. I'm actually starving.

Janice, as per Wonderbot

So Caprio came up with a new option: He could let the mom out of the fine if she agreed to buy her daughter breakfast. Janice agreed and the family left the courtroom, but not without giving the judge a hug.

How a Kind Judge Chose Compassion Instead of Punishment

It's worth asking the question: is legal punishment always necessary? Of course not. In many cases, compassion is better than punishment and, fortunately, Judge Caprio, realized that if he ticketed the mom he would be depriving her daughters.

It's great to see, and a good reminder to be compassionate, whether you're a judge, parent, or a boss.

More uplifting news

lead with compassion
 "True compassion means not only feeling another's pain but also being moved to help relieve it." - Daniel Goleman

Hot Stories

Pamela Anderson Opens Up About Her 9 Disastrous Weddings
Why Pamela Anderson Can't Stop Getting Married

Pamela Anderson has it all: beauty, fame and success. So why can’t the most famous blonde find her fairytale ending? Why is Pamela so unlucky in love and what dark secrets lie behind her seemingly glamorous life?

Keep ReadingShow less
Life Stories
Woman at a restaurant's window and two teen employees.

Teens Applauded For the Way They Handled This Angry Customer

Instagram/ @kekessnowballs

Working in customer service can be challenging, especially when you’re dealing with rude and demanding clients. That’s particularly true for some teens, who work these jobs for part-time money and are often bullied by adults. Perhaps that’s why people are applauding these teen girls for the way they expertly handled an over-the-top customer.

Keep ReadingShow less
Uplifting News
Man standing with two daughters, a black purse and a handwritten note (inset)

Grieving Daughter Finds Note In Fossil Purse While Thrifting

Courtesy Anna Harp and Courtesy of Abrielle Clausing (via People.com)

Thrifting can net all sorts of treasures. Shoppers can snatch up everything from vintage clothes to mid-century modern furniture to kitschy knick-knacks, all without breaking the bank.

But for one grieving woman, she found a hidden gem that was truly priceless.

Keep ReadingShow less
Uplifting News